• A letter to my readers

    Posted on October 12, 2010 by in blog, Personal & Life

    Dear Friends,

    I think it’s time I did some explaining.

    Jimmy Moore recently had a reader ask him a question that I’m sure has been on many minds. They wanted to know why many low-carb representatives were not “skinny”. I think it’s certainly a valid question. It’s also well timed as this is something I’ve been needing to address myself and wasn’t sure where to start.

    I can’t speak for anyone else. There are many bloggers like myself, putting their lives in the public eye and sharing what they’ve learned – mistakes and all. As of late I’ve been sharing a lot less, and I’ll admit it’s mostly out of shame.

    To be succinct, I’ve simply fallen apart. I’ve tried to put on a brave face and pretend it’s not happening, but I simply can’t do that anymore. It’s not fair to me and it’s not fair to you.

    On the low-carb cruise earlier this year I was sadly about 25-30 lbs from my goal weight, and this was after losing about 35 lbs in the previous months while trying The 6 Week Cure. Despite the fact that I’ve been low-carbing for almost 10 years, I’ve had a really bumpy ride. After being diagnosed with Fibromyalgia and Depression almost 12 years go, I’ve never quite been the same person. I’m not very active, though I’d love to be. I require more sleep than the average person. It takes a lot to keep me going each day, and my engine seems to run on fumes most of the time. So when I found the low-carb lifestyle in 2001, I was ecstatic. I was feeling better, looking better and my health issues were slowing resolving themselves. I was able to go a long time without any anti-depressants.  I hit my goal weight and felt better than I ever had – with the exception of still fighting fatigue. While I did have more energy than I’d experience before low-carbing, it honestly wouldn’t take much to be more than I had before.

    So I maintained for a good 6 months or so. Then life kicked us in the head… hard. My husband was let go from a good job, our only income, because of a company buy out. We struggled to care for two babies and ourselves for 9 months. I found myself seeking comfort from food once again. When I realized what I was doing to myself, I struggled to get it under control. Sadly I’d already started gaining back the weight.

    Since then I’ve lost and regained countless times. But I’ve never given up and I’ve managed to do pretty good most of the time. Now fast forward to last year. I’m doing okay… still not at my goal weight, but not anywhere near my highest weight.  My eating was mostly low-carb, with the occasional bad choice thrown in, which is likely why I wasn’t making any real progress in the weight-loss area. Then again we fell into some financial difficulties thanks to a floundering economy and a main income that involved sales. My stress coping methods, quite frankly, stink to high heaven. Again I fed my emotions, and this time I found myself not caring. I have no real excuses for this.  It just is what it is.

    Within a very short amount of time I had gained back all my weight, plus a little. It left me feeling like a huge failure, and I beat myself up daily over it. Then I learned about The 6 Week Cure and decided to give it a try. It worked well for me, taking off almost 35 lbs. The other motivating factor was the cruise. I didn’t want to show up on the cruise weighing more than I ever have in my life.

    After coming home from the cruise, I continued to use the 6 Week Cure, but suddenly found it difficult. I have no idea why when it seemed so incredibly easy before.  Our financial situation continued to get worse. Shortly after that full blown depression set in. I kept telling myself I could handle it. I could eat right and it would be fine. But I was lying to myself. This was more than even diet can handle.

    I don’t know if any of you have ever experienced fatigue and depression to the extend that you no longer care about… well, pretty much anything. If you have, you’ll understand what I’m saying. If you haven’t, I just ask that you keep an open mind. Please don’t label people with these issues as lazy or hypochondriacs. It’s much more complicated than just waking up each morning and saying “I will feel great today!” It just doesn’t work that way. You wake up and wonder if you’ll have the strength to even get out of bed. When you do finally drag yourself out, you then have to find the strength to get through the morning, then the afternoon, then the evening. Depending on your responsibilities, that can be overwhelming. For me it certainly has been. I’ve tried to maintain this blog, somewhat unsuccessfully, write for various entities, pursue my photography career, care for a home and family, and homeschool my two children. It’s a lot to handle for a healthy person – it’s all but impossible for someone in my current state.

    Cooking became a burden, as did the clean up required afterwards. It took up energy I quite frankly didn’t have. So we started living off of fast food and quick meals. The kind of stuff that I would never have touched before. But when you have an extremely limited budget, as well as extremely limited energy, those  boxes of spaghetti and hamburger helper look pretty good. I’m sure you can guess what happened then. I gained back the weight I’d lost earlier in the year. I’m now once again at my highest weight of 203. Something I promised myself I’d never see again.

    It’s very hard to admit this to you, but I have to. I had to admit to myself recently that I’ve fallen apart and I need help. Thankfully a friend pointed me in the direction of clinic that works on a sliding scale, so I can once again seek medical care without the added stress of large bills I can’t pay. (You may remember I’m the only one in my family without medical coverage.)

    I took the initiative to get help last week. After a fasting blood test, we discovered I’m very low in Vit. D, which should be no big surprise considering my fatigue. It makes me wonder how long I’ve been deficient. I’d guess for a very long time. I started my Vit. D therapy today and at my next appointment later this week will discuss going back on anti-depressants again, at least until things are under control.

    My plans also include regular exercise, even if it’s just walking around the block, and rigid meal planning, all induction friendly.

    In short I’m starting over my friends.

    Recently I was named as a low-carb hero in an article someone wrote. While I feel very honored, I also feel shame. If I was placed there because I am trying to share information and help others, then I am thankful. If I was placed there because of my success, I certainly don’t deserve the honor. Another article I read recently discussed my long-term success, saying I’d maintained for 5 years. I apologize to everyone for this misconception. I thought I’d mentioned my weight struggles many times on here, but apparently I haven’t made it obvious enough. I don’t want to deceive anyone in any way.

    I guess this was my long answer to the above question. Why am I not skinny? Because I messed up. Because, like the rest of you, I’m human and I make bad decisions sometimes. Because I don’t handle stress well at all. I must reiterate that it is NOT the low-carb lifestyle that has failed. I failed.

    It’s been hard to type these words. To admit in front of thousands of people that I’ve dropped the ball in such a huge way. But I hope that I’ll emerge stronger for it and more determined to make this work once and for all. I also hope that any of you who are struggling will see that we have to just keep plugging along and doing our best. I always say that falling down is not failure, it’s not getting back up that is the problem. I fell down, and for a while I just laid there and wallowed in it. But this isn’t me.  So I’ve picked myself back up and will continue on. I hope you will all continue this journey with me.  It will take me a bit to get moving … I have a lot to overcome to be myself again. But I’ve done it before and I can do it again. I hope you’ll stick with me while I rediscover the joys of this wonderful lifestyle.

    Many hugs to my wonderful friends all over the world,

    Amy

    Print Friendly
  • Paulikate

    Amy – one of the reasons I admire you so much is that you are honest. It takes a strong person to explain this all to your readers, and I am sure that most will appreciate your candor. You are a real mom, just doing the best you can do. We all fall down. I’ll be around to try to support you when you need it. I know I need it, too. Best wishes as you start back on your journey to better health.

  • Penny

    It’s ok! Life is bumpy. You are doing your best. I don’t think you should be ashamed. I think you are normal. I am glad you are getting help and are on the road to feeling better.
    God Bless you!
    Penny

  • Haley

    Amy, your candor is such an inspiration. Knowing that there is a “real person” behind the words makes what you do so worthy. I do not want weight or exercise advice from someone who looks like a super model, it’s not genuine and therefore unbelievable – for me anyway.

    Thank you for sharing your struggles – I would far rather have my daughter looked up to you than someone fake and unwilling to admit their own slip ups.

  • Anonymous

    Hugs back to you, Amy, and best of luck. I’ve had all the experiences you have — about 14 years of low-carbing during which I went from 204 lbs. down to 145, and since then have been see-sawing between 150 and somewhere near 165. It’s frustrating at times, but I keep reminding myself that even at 164 I’m 40 lbs. lighter than I used to be. Due to damage from past surgeries I can’t do much in the way of exercise — walking a slow block is about it for me — so I have to rely completely on diet. So when I get discouraged I just start back on induction for three or four weeks, then go up the line through the phases to maintenance again, staying there until my clothes start to feel uncomfortably tight, when it’s time to go back onto induction again.

    The recipes and ideas I’ve picked up from the internet have been very helpful in keeping me from tipping the scales at 200+ again. And some of those recipes and ideas came directly from you. So don’t ever feel that the fact that you aren’t perfect keeps you from being helpful to others. You’re one of those who has helped me immensely, and I owe you thanks for it.

  • Chris Lemmen

    Amy, this post makes you even more of a hero in my eyes. I personally am not looking for a perfect person to follow. I need someone relate-able. That’s you. If not for you, I would be tipping the scales close to 290 by now.

    Last year when you turned me on to the 6 Week Cure I knew someone had finally shown me the answer. I lost 18 lbs very quickly but also found it hard to follow after that. I fell off the wagon just a few months after starting and gained back all that weight. 5 weeks ago I started Atkins and have lost 20lbs since and have never felt better.

    Reading your story proves to me that even though we may fall once in a while we can all get back up, dust ourselves off and keep on going. I wish you all the best and I know you can get back to your goal weight with ease. All of us who follow your blog have no doubt there I’m sure.

    Chris.

  • Lea

    Dear Amy, thank you for sharing your heartfelt and very candid story, you are not a failure—you only fail in life when you give up–remember that. you are strong and we are all allowed to fall off the horse. you are getting back on the horse and initially they look like Clydesdales and in the end they become ponies……keep up the good work and continue to inspire us as you will yourself. I am rooting for you–
    your admiring reader
    Lea

  • Elisaannh

    The one thing I have always hated about the low carb community is the overall snobbery of LC’ers. No other diet group has had so many perfectionists. Purists have driven me away from low carb as a shared interest with others. I wonder why so many feel they must live up to some crazy LC standard?

    What made you feel you had to confess to being human? LC isn’t a cult or a religion. It is simply a way of eating that feels good and has some health benefits. You cannot fail LC, not even as a writer or representative or as one who struggles with it. One can be obese or skinny or anything in-between and still be interested in promoting LC. There is nothing that has to be proven, I am never interested in before and after testimonies of LC’ers, I want to know how every day people manage to work through the challenges of incorporating LC into their eating habits. Perfectionism isn’t what LC is all about, it is about how we manage to work it, bite by bite, meal to meal, year to year. It is about how it benefits our body and minds, not about how much we weight we might lose. Life happens, LC feels good…no apologies needed. I can only admire your tenacity to seek improvement in your own life, through all the struggles and set backs!

  • http://diabeticmediterraneandiet.com Steveparkermd

    It took a lot of courage for you to admit this, Amy, and I admire you for that and other things. We forgive you for being human. Don’t give up.

    -Steve

  • Jimmy Moore

    We love you, Amy, and wish on the best for you. As you know, I too am dealing with these issues myself and we’re both gonna succeed as it as long as we stay engaged. Sure, there will be the naysayers who will mock us as pitiful examples of low-carb. But let ‘em talk. This is about OUR health and nobody else. Do what’s right for you! :)

  • Whitakercrew

    I started going to a new doctor today and he gave me the low-carb diet. I’ve never really done a particular diet, not long enough to matter anyway, so I got my laptop out, searched “healthy low carb living” and your blog is the first thing I came upon. What a blessing. Your story really hit home for me. My biggest weight was 233lbs and I’ve hit that twice, and both times were litteraly the rock bottom for me. Thankfully, through God’s grace, I’ve lost 40lbs, and with His Grace I have 30-40 more pounds to go. You’ve been an inspiration to me and I’m really glad I found your site. God bless you as you travel down life’s road, whatever it may bring, just know you have someone from little ol’ Alabama rooting for you.

  • CherylEm

    Amy Dungan, you are one First Class Lady. Only a woman with the utmost integrity, eternal compassion for her fellow man, and a love of life and all that is good could have written such a blog post today.

    We love you, Amy Dungan, and don’t you ever forget it.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3LAWZOIZR4PFCH4LFH6NSRKBKA TJ

    Amy. Love you. Nuff said.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    I posted a comment yesterday, but it seems to have disappeared. ???

    Thanks so much to all of you. I appreciate the support and encouragement. It has given me extra motivation to get back into the groove of things. It’s also made me cry (in a good way. LOL) Shame on me forgetting what a supportive and wonderful group of readers I have. Thank you for taking the time to comment… it means a lot to me. :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    I have to agree with you Elisaannh. There is way too much perfection preached. In a perfect world we’d all eat organic home-grown veggies and grass fed meats, while sweets of any kind would be shunned completely. That’s not reality though. Some people can do it, but most can’t. I’m certainly not one that can – and I’ve tried. We have to make things work for us with the situation we are in.

    While I’m sure the depression has been doing some talking for me lately, I believe my apologies are mostly for the fear I’ve inadvertently deceived my readers about my weight struggles. I’m too hard on myself, and I realize that at times. Thanks for taking the time to leave your thoughts. I appreciate them very much. :)

  • http://twitter.com/meltingmama Beth Sheldon-Badore

    <3

  • http://twitter.com/meltingmama Beth Sheldon-Badore

    <3

  • Jennifer Eloff

    Dear Amy, I almost cried reading your story – my heart hurts for you. I’m so sorry. I’ve dealt with depression in my life too (over my mother’s actions) and know how that upsets the body chemistry and one gains weight very easily. Also, one craves carbs and one simply stops caring about good choices as you said.

    You’re a wonderful friend and I’m sure a wonderful wife and mother. You’re also a very smart lady and people adore you and I know Jesus loves you!

    If anyone can get through something as tough as this, it is you in my opinion. I believe you will go on to help and comfort many more people and in doing so, you will find your answer to permanent weight loss along the way. You certainly know how to lose weight. Losing 35 lbs like that is phenomenal actually. Dig deep and you will find the strength to take one day at a time. Don’t be impatient. That is key.

    ((((HUGggggggsss)))) ‘cos you need them and please don’t feel you can’t help people when you have struggles yourself. To the contrary….you are very knowledgeable and you are still helping folks.

    I’m going to add you to my daily prayers and also your finances. You’ll get there. I know you will. It’s tough times for many right now with the awful economy. We’ve also had some finance problems and fear of running out of money just recently and have had to scramble to find ways to make extra income (my DH has been retired after he was laid off, since the age of 43). Who knows why we have trials and all of us do, but “it is a good life unless we weaken”. That is my mother-in-law’s favorite saying and she has not had an easy life either by any means.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/DARdreams DAR

    Amy, you are still one of my low carb heroes! (http://www.squidoo.com/top-20-low-carb-heroes) My criteria was stated as “These people are heroes because in the face of unrelenting opposition, they continue to present the truth to millions of people who can benefit from a low carb lifestyle.” You do this!

    There is no reason for you to feel ashamed. Most, if not all of us struggle to maintain our weight loss. I am constantly fighting to get the last 10 lbs of my 60 lb loss back off. I also struggle to keep my BGL under 100 at all times. It’s an ongoing journey; there’s no arriving and then putting our feet up. And sometimes we end up having to walk the same path all over again.

    I also have many health issues that sap my strength and make getting out of bed very difficult mentally and physically a lot of the time. I’m thankful that my kids are adults now because 9 years of homeschooling took a huge toll on my body. I can really empathize with you being in the midst of it still. Most people who haven’t homeschooled have no idea how much work it is!

    Have you been tested for adrenal fatigue? It makes dealing with stress extremely difficult and can masquerade as depression, Fibromyalgia, Chronic Fatigue, etc. I have been trying to recover from it for years and it’s a very long and difficult process.

    I’m praying for your recovery as you deal with all the stresses in your life. Honestly and openly sharing them with all of us just reinforces my opinion that you are a hero!

  • Lyrica7

    You should check out a website called stopthethyroidmadness.com-all your symptoms and especially the low Vitamin D (a big red flag) and depression are symptoms of a thyroid disorder. Fibromyalgia is often alleviated when proper thyroid treatment and medications are given.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you so much DAR. No, I’ve not been tested for that, but it’s sure something I’ll keep in mind. Thanks for the encouragement! :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Jennifer. I know you’ve struggled too. Hugs back to you! :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thanks Beth. That one little gesture says a lot. :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Back at ya brother!

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Cheryl. I’m very touched by your words. I’ll come back and read them anytime I’m feeling lost. :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Congrats on your success so far Whitakercrew! Thank you for taking the time to comment and for your encouragement. It means a lot to me.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thanks Jimmy. You’ve been an encouragement to me and I appreciate you and Christine so much!

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thanks Steve. I’m going to keep plugging along. Thank you for always being supportive and a faithful reader. :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you so much Lea. I love your analogy about the Clydesdales and ponies. That’s exactly how it feels. I appreciate your comment and support!

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Chris, thank you for your nice words. I’m glad you are doing well and we’ll get through this together! :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you enelkay. I appreciate your comment. Congrats on maintaining a good part of your loss and keep it up. We’ll all eventually figure this out, right? :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thanks Penny. I appreciate it!

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Haley. I know you go through similar stuff and I’m glad to call you my friend!

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Paulikate. It’s friends like you that keep me going. :)

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thanks for the link Lyrica7! I’ve had my thyroid checked several times, but it always comes back normal. TSH has been on the high side at times (using the newest scale) but my free t3 seems to be fine, so drs haven’t felt comfortable treating me for thyroid issues. I do have many of the symptoms though. And both my parents are hypothyroid, so not sure where that may or may not play into the equation.

  • http://heartofacountryhome.wordpress.com/ Jillian

    Amy, I feel your pain! My story is so similar to yours. I know how it feels to feel like a failure. It hurts. But we’re also alike in another way…WE DON’T GIVE UP!

    Hang in there, my friend. Hopefully success will come our way.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Jillian. We can do this! :)

  • Debbiecdepot-LC

    Amy, so sorry you are going through this. I sure know the feeling of complete hopelessness, and I’ve been there – as my top weight and totally unable to muster up any sort of desire to do anything about it. I agree with the poster who thinks maybe your thyroid could be implicated. What doctors say is “fine” and what really IS fine about thyroid readings are two totally different things! I’m dealing with thyroid myself now after being diagnosed with Hasimoto’s disease earlier this year, and in retrospect I think my thyroid has been out of whack for at least a dozen years – but I was not educated enough about the subject to contradict the doctors who said that I was “fine”.

    Now if I could just lose weight again also. I still wonder what the solution is for low carbers like me who have stayed the course and stayed low carb – following the “rules” and yet stalled for nearly a year a least still 100 pounds from goal.

  • Lynndunning

    With depression, FM and easy weight gain, you sound pretty hypothyroid. Check out http://www.stopthethyroidmadness.com for detailed info. Sadly, most people take decades to get dx, as 95% of docs know nothing about it.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    Thank you Lynn. I’m still looking for answers and still haven’t completely ruled out thyroid.

  • Lynn

    The language of ‘ruling it out’ suggests that you kinda think you don’t have it. It’s hard to describe to someone unfamiliar with the situation, but honestly docs will only diagnose hypo when the markers are indescribably bad. Plus, they usually do the wrong tests and don’t know how to interpret them.

    With your family history, obvious hypo symptoms and bad labs, I don’t think that you need to rule this out; you prob need to treat it. You would also benefit from thoroughly reading around STIM. I hope you do soon. Blessings, Lynn.

  • http://www.healthylowcarbliving.com Amy Dungan

    I’m actually more towards that I do, but I don’t know how to treat it since I can’t get help from my doctor. My husband’s doctor on the other hand might be helpful – but I can’t afford her so I’m having to work that out too. I currently have some OTC stuff I’m gonna try and see if it makes a difference. I’ll keep you posted and thanks again for the encouragement!

Website is Protected by Wordpress Protection from eDarpan.com.